OPINION: THE ILLUSION OF EFFECTIVENESS (I)
Montenegro has written the same prohibition twice, sixteen years apart. It has enforced it neither time. The problem is not a law that is missing, but a law that exists and does not work.
Two sentences
In 2010 the legislature wrote: “The established limit values and target values, long-term objectives and critical levels must not be exceeded” (Art. 8(4) of the Law on Air Protection, Official Gazette of Montenegro No. 25/10). In 2026 it wrote again that limit values “must not be exceeded” (Art. 6(5) of the Law on Air Protection, Official Gazette of Montenegro No. 117/2026). Between the two sentences, what changed was the verb form, the number of the Official Gazette and the model: the new law, as its own explanatory memorandum states, transposes Directive (EU) 2024/2881. The air in Pljevlja has not changed.
More than three years ago I wrote that “in the books and national reports everything looks ‘perfect’” (Kojičić, Vijesti, 24 Feb 2023). The 2026 law is precisely such a book: modern, aligned and, for the first time in the history of Montenegrin law, granting individuals a right to compensation for damage to health (Art. 56). The question of this series is therefore not whether the text is good. The question is why a good text produces no effect at all.
Validity is not effectiveness
Legal theory has long distinguished a norm that is valid from a norm that is effective. The first is a matter of procedure: the law was adopted, published and entered into force. The second is a matter of reality: do institutions behave as the norm prescribes? Håkan Hydén reduces this to a precise formula: a legal rule becomes a norm only when three conditions are met — will, knowledge and system possibilities (Hydén, 2022, p. 10). Without will, there is no application. Without knowledge, that is, without reliable data, there is no verification. Without resources, deadlines and procedure, there is no enforcement.
The European Court of Human Rights has a single sentence for the same idea, almost half a century old: the Convention guarantees not rights that are “theoretical or illusory” but rights that are “practical and effective” (Airey v. Ireland, 1979, § 24). When a norm is valid but does not work, the result is what I called, in an analysis submitted to the parliamentary committees, the illusion of effectiveness: a text which, read in isolation, looks complete, but in reality depends on decisions that no one is obliged to take (Kojičić, The Illusion of Effectiveness, July 2026). This series of ten columns removes that illusion layer by layer — from the text of the law, through measurement and data, to money and accountability.
Sixteen years of one sentence
The 2010 sentence had sixteen years to produce an effect. According to the annual reports of the Environmental Protection Agency itself, the daily limit value for PM10 in Pljevlja was exceeded every year from 2010 to 2024: at least 64 days (2010), at most 217 (2012), against 35 permitted. In total, that is 2,147 days of exceedance against 525 permitted (Agency, annual reports on the state of the environment 2010–2024). Not in a single year was the prohibition respected.
The new sentence began in the same way. In 2026 Pljevlja had 26 days of exceedance in January, 9 in February and 10 in March (Agency, monthly air quality reports for 2026). All 35 days that the regulation permits for the whole year were used up by the end of February; the annual limit was crossed in March. By the end of September there had been 53 days.
In March 2023 I wrote that “the state is not able to comply with the laws it has itself enacted” (Kojičić, Vijesti, 9 Mar 2023). More than three years later, that sentence is confirmed not by the author, but by the Agency.
The circle: a new regulation instead of applying the old one
Pljevlja has had an air quality plan since 2013 (Agency and Municipality of Pljevlja, Short-Term Action Plan, 2017). The exceedances continued every year. Parliament then unanimously adopted a special law for a single municipality — the Law on Special Measures for Environmental Protection in the Municipality of Pljevlja (Official Gazette of Montenegro No. 2/2026). Unlike the general law, this lex specialis is precise: the procurement of air purifiers for public institutions within 60 days and an office of the Ministry in Pljevlja within 120 days (Art. 8), with a cost estimate of one to five million euros in the explanatory memorandum. The law was published in the Official Gazette on 5 January 2026; the 60-day deadline expired in March 2026, and the 120-day deadline in the first half of May 2026. In June the Municipality offered free premises for the office, and the Ministry explained the failure by a lack of budgetary funds (Vijesti, 23 Jun 2026). To this day the office has not been opened; a vacancy notice was announced for “soon” (Espona, 25 Sep 2026).
The third step of the circle is the new general law. It does not repeal the old implementing regulations, but extends their life: until new ones are adopted, for which it gives itself two years, the earlier regulations apply (Art. 64 of the Law on Air Protection). In other words, precisely those regulations that went unapplied for sixteen years.
This is not a coincidence, but a method. I described it in 2023, writing about the legal order as a whole: “Since they are not implemented, ‘new’ regulations are imposed as ‘new’ solutions” (Kojičić, Vijesti, 24 Feb 2023). The 2026 Law on Air Protection is a textbook example of that sentence.
The European yardstick
The European Court of Human Rights described the same mechanism in a case in which the City Council of Valencia adopted noise regulations and then failed to enforce them. The Court found that the council had “tolerated, and thus contributed to, the repeated flouting of the rules which it itself had established”, and concluded: “Regulations to protect guaranteed rights serve little purpose if they are not duly enforced” (Moreno Gómez v. Spain, 2004, § 61). The key words are “the rules which it itself had established”. This is not someone else’s rule that the authorities do not understand, but their own rule that they do not apply.
The Court of Justice of the European Union goes a step further. For an infringement, “exceeding the limit values is … sufficient” (Commission v. Bulgaria, C-488/15, § 69), and “it is irrelevant whether the failure to fulfil obligations is the result of intention or negligence … or of technical difficulties” (§ 76). Bulgaria was found in breach for systematic and continuous exceedance from 2007 to 2014 — eight years. Pljevlja counts fifteen years in a row. Montenegro is not a member of the Union, but it has knowingly transposed the European air quality rules into its own law. It transposed the text; the yardstick by which that text is checked in Europe has stayed on the other side of the border.
“Give the law time”
The most serious objection runs as follows: the law has been in force since 15 August 2026, and it is too early to assess it. The objection would be strong if the problem were the novelty of the law. The problem, however, is not novelty, but continuity. First, the new law itself extends the life of old regulations that were not applied. Second, a more precise law — a lex specialis with numerical deadlines and an estimated cost — was not implemented within any of its deadlines. If a law that has deadlines does not work, there is no reason to expect that a law that postpones them will. Third, the air did not wait: in September, when the new law was already in force, the limit was exceeded in Pljevlja four times (Agency, monthly report for September 2026). Time was not lacking. Application was.
A sentence that repeats itself
The 2026 law makes no grammatical mistake. “Must not be exceeded” is a clear, categorical prohibition — just as clear as the one of 2010. That is exactly why it is devastating. A prohibition that is repeated but not applied ceases to be a norm and becomes a ritual: the state pronounces it, the citizen breathes it.
In March 2023 I wrote that “in the case of Pljevlja under consideration, the law does not rule” (Kojičić, Vijesti, 18 Mar 2023). Since then, one special and one general law have been adopted. The sentence is still true. In the next column: a law that postpones its own deadlines.
Author Jovan Kojicic, professor of law, a DAAD alumnus and head of the MP Logo Vox legal clinic for Vijesti.me

